History of the Broken Arrow Elks Lodge

The Jolly Corks

The Elks fraternal order traces its roots to New York City in 1868, when British actor Charles Vivian gathered a circle of minstrel-show performers into a social club. Calling themselves the "Jolly Corks," the group used Vivian's cork-drawing game as an initiation (the slowest player always bought the drinks). By the end of 1868, this club had formally adopted the name Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks.

The organization’s founding was prompted by tragedy: a fellow actor had died from lack of medical funds, inspiring the group to support one another. From the outset the Elks were dedicated to charitable service and mutual aid, upholding pillars of Charity, Justice, Brotherly Love and Fidelity, ideals that guided the lodge’s community work.

Broken Arrow Elks Opera House

Broken Arrow’s original lodge meetings took place in the historic Dorris Opera House (built 1898). In the 1910s it was renamed the "Elks Theatre" and became the official home of the local lodge. This grand Queen Anne–style theater hosted plays, concerts, and dances, reflecting the Elks’ role as cultural patrons in early Broken Arrow.

Elks Theater Advertisements

The Elks Theater in Broken Arrow featured touring vaudeville and theatrical productions. In 1920, former major-league baseball star Mike Donlin appeared in the comedy “Turn to the Right” at the Broken Arrow Elks Theater. The newspaper advertisement below promoted that show, illustrating the lodge’s entertainment programming in the early 20th century.